Every adult in Brooklyn should have three incapacity documents: a durable power of attorney (who manages your finances if you cannot), a health care proxy (who makes medical decisions), and a living will (your end-of-life wishes). Without them, your family must petition the court for an Article 81 guardianship — a slow, public, and costly proceeding heard in the Kings County courts. Three signed documents prevent it.
These documents work during your lifetime, complementing the wills and trusts that take effect at death.
The NY Statutory Short Form Power of Attorney (2021 reform)
Definition — Power of attorney (POA): A document naming an agent to act for you in financial and legal matters. “Durable” means it survives your incapacity.
New York overhauled its power of attorney in June 2021 (General Obligations Law Article 5, Title 15). Key features of the modern statutory form under GOL 5-1501:
- Signing requirements: You must sign (or direct someone to sign in your presence), have it notarized, and signed by two witnesses — one of whom may be the notary. This two-witness rule was new in the 2021 reform.
- Substantial compliance: The 2021 law forgives minor wording errors that previously voided forms — a relief for Brooklyn families who used outdated documents.
- Penalties for refusal: Third parties (banks) that unreasonably refuse a valid POA can face liability, addressing the old problem of banks rejecting proxies.
A POA lets your agent pay bills, manage your Bay Ridge property, handle a co-op, and deal with Medicaid applications if you become incapacitated.
The modern combined form and gifting authority
Before 2021, New York used a separate Statutory Gifts Rider to authorize gifts over $500. The 2021 reform folded gifting authority into the main form — there is no longer a separate rider. If you want your agent to make gifts (important for Medicaid and estate-tax planning), the modern form includes a section to grant and customize that authority. Without it, your agent generally cannot give away your assets.
Health Care Proxy (Public Health Law Article 29-C)
Definition — Health care proxy: A document appointing an agent to make medical decisions when you cannot speak for yourself.
Under New York Public Health Law Article 29-C, you appoint a health care agent who steps in only when a physician determines you lack capacity. The agent decides on treatment, hospitals, and care consistent with your wishes. The form requires two witnesses (the agent cannot be a witness). One trusted agent — and a backup — is enough.
Living will vs. health care proxy
Definition — Living will: A written statement of your wishes about life-sustaining treatment (ventilators, feeding tubes, resuscitation). A health care proxy names a person; a living will states instructions. They work best together — the proxy decides, guided by the living will.
New York recognizes living wills through case law (the O’Connor standard requires clear and convincing evidence of your wishes), which is exactly why a written living will is so valuable: it provides that evidence.
MOLST and end-of-life directives
A MOLST (Medical Orders for Life-Sustaining Treatment) is a bright-pink medical order form signed by a physician, used by seriously ill patients to record specific orders (DNR, intubation preferences). It travels with the patient across Brooklyn hospitals and nursing homes and is honored by EMS. A MOLST complements — it does not replace — a health care proxy.
What happens without these documents: Article 81 guardianship
Definition — Article 81 guardianship: A court proceeding under New York Mental Hygiene Law (MHL) Article 81 in which a judge appoints a guardian for an incapacitated adult who left no planning documents.
If a Brooklyn resident becomes incapacitated with no POA or health care proxy, the family must file an Article 81 petition in the Supreme Court, Kings County. The process involves a court evaluator, a hearing, and ongoing court reporting — often taking months and thousands of dollars. The guardian the judge appoints may not be whom you would have chosen. Three signed documents avoid this entirely.
Where Article 81 guardianship is heard for Brooklyn residents
For a Brooklyn (Kings County) resident, an Article 81 guardianship petition is filed in the Supreme Court, Kings County (the Guardianship Part), not the Surrogate’s Court. The Surrogate’s Court handles probate and SCPA 17-A guardianships of the developmentally disabled; Article 81 adult guardianships go to Supreme Court.
Frequently asked questions
Is my old New York power of attorney still valid? A POA validly executed before June 2021 generally remains valid, but many families update to the 2021 form for its broader bank-acceptance protections. Have it reviewed.
Does a power of attorney work after I die? No. A POA ends at death; from that point your will and executor take over. Incapacity documents and estate documents cover different phases.
Can one person be my agent for everything? You can name the same trusted person as financial agent and health care agent, but they are separate documents with separate signing rules.
Do I need a lawyer for these forms? The forms are statutory, but errors in witnessing or gifting authority cause bank rejections and Medicaid problems. A brief review is worthwhile.
Get your incapacity documents in order
A single consultation can put all three documents in place correctly. Book 30 minutes with Russel Morgan or see our contact page.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.